The listings featured on this site are from companies from which this site receives compensation. This influences where, how and in what order such listings appear on this site.
Adv Disclosure
We aim to provide valuable content and useful comparison features to our visitors through our free online resource. It's important to note that we receive advertising compensation from companies featured on our site, which influences the positioning and order in which brands (and/or their products) are displayed, as well as the assigned score. Please be aware that the inclusion of company listings on this page doesn't imply endorsement. We don't feature all providers available in the market. Any information presented on this page, including pricing, is subject to change without notice. We want to emphasize that we disclaim all representations and warranties concerning the accuracy of the information provided on this site, unless otherwise explicitly stated in our Terms of Use
Close
defaultdefaultdefault
Prudent Pet Insurance Review
In a nutshell: Prudent Pet Insurance provides customizable coverage for dogs and cats, with wellness add-ons available.
Prudent Pet Insurance Review
In a nutshell: Prudent Pet Insurance provides customizable coverage for dogs and cats, with wellness add-ons available.
Prudent Pet Insurance Review
In a nutshell: Prudent Pet Insurance provides customizable coverage for dogs and cats, with wellness add-ons available.
default

Overview

Launched in 2018, Prudent Pet Insurance has become a popular option thanks to its transparent pricing, customizable coverage, and high quality customer service. Their website is easy to navigate, and all customers can get a free, instant quote online and a 30-day money back guarantee.

Their clear policies ensure customers know exactly what the insurance covers. Customers can expect to pay a standard amount in terms of costs. Their flexible pricing gives you the chance to add extra wellness coverage for your pets that many other insurance companies neglect to offer.

Prudent Pet Insurance stands out by offering flexible deductible options starting from $100 up to $1000 with a reimbursement model of 70%, 80%, or 90%. They do not include any exotic pets. Still, customers can customize pet care coverage and only pay for what they need. For assistance, customer support is readily available through a number of different channels.

Policies

Prudent Pet Insurance now offers three straightforward coverage plans along with optional add-ons, giving customers the flexibility to pay for what they need. Prudent Pet Insurance has reimbursement options of 70%, 80%, and 90% and annual deductible options of $100, $250, $500, and $1000. All plans come with optional coverage toward exam and wellness fees.

Prudent Pet Insurance will accept dogs and cats of all ages and breeds. Customers can take their pet to any licensed vet in the US or Canada, including specialists and emergency care providers. All policies come with a 5-day waiting period for accident coverage, a 14-day waiting period for illness coverage, and a 6-month waiting period for all knee and ligament issues.

Accident Only:

Covers bite wounds, prescribed alternative therapies, broken bones, injuries to teeth and mouth, emergencies, hospitalizations, prescription meds, radiology and diagnostic tests, surgery, specialized care, and swallowed objects with annual benefits up to $10,000 with customizable deductible and reimbursement

Essential:

Covers Accident Only injuries + cancer treatment, growths, congenital birth defects, digestive illness, eye/ear/skin conditions, hereditary conditions, hip dysplasia, and urinary infections up to $10,000 + $250 toward behavioral disorders

Unlimited:

Covers all included in Essential Plan + cash coverage of boarding kennel and cattery fees, loss due to theft or stray, mortality, and vacation cancellation with unlimited maximum payout

Limitations

Coverage depends on the plan that you choose. Like any pet insurance provider, Prudent comes with its limitations.

Keep in mind that they will not cover pre-existing conditions. Prudent Pet Insurance defines pre-existing as: “as a medical condition which first occurred or showed clinical sign(s) before the effective date of your policy or which occurred or showed clinical sign(s) during the policy waiting period.” To avoid any denied claims, make sure to get a wellness exam prior to signing up to establish a baseline record of your pet’s health.

Accident coverage includes injuries and emergencies related to accidents, like torn ligaments, bite wounds, broken bones, lodged foreign objects, and ingestion of toxic substances.

Illness coverage includes the treatment of all kinds of illnesses, including cancer, arthritis, allergies, digestive problems, and UTIs. Plans also cover hereditary and congenital conditions, dental disease, and destructive behavioral issues.

You can save in the long-run by including the preventative care add-on which comes at an extra cost. However, bear in mind the extent of what the add on offers and whether it makes sense for your budget in the long run. There are many examples to list such as dental work, deworming, spay and neuter, and an overall wellness exam on top of many more.

In addition, Prudent Pet only covers cats and dogs. If you own any exotic animals such as birds or reptiles, this company wouldn’t suit your needs. Cosmetic procedures and breeding costs are also not covered.

Cost

The cost of your policy depends on a number of different factors. You’ll pay the least amount for the most basic coverage options, but you’ll save in the future with more comprehensive coverage. The cost varies considerably based on the age of your pet, the breed, and your state of residence. Prudent also gives a 10% discount for adding another pet.

Let’s say you live in Arizona and have a 13-year-old male cocker spaniel. The Essential plan with a $500 deductible and 80% reimbursement would cost $217.90 per month.

A 4-year-old female labradoodle living in Arizona would cost $53.18 per month with a $500 deductible and 80% reimbursement.

An 8-year-old domestic shorthair cat living in Arizona would cost $41.71 per month with a $500 deductible and 80% reimbursement.

Customer Support

Prudent Pet Insurance offers reliable customer support. You can contact them online via email or even just call their customer support helpline. If you have any problems or inquiries the staff are there to help. Submitting claims online is fast, and you can expect a quick response. If you are entitled to a reimbursement, Prudent Pet will provide a convenient direct deposit.

So what do customers have to say about their experience? The company received an impressive 4.8 out of 5 star rating on Trustpilot out of hundreds of reviews. Customers love the excellent service, flexible coverage options, and transparent policy.

prosAndCons icon
Pros
  • High satisfaction rating
  • Customizable plans
  • Free, instant online quote
prosAndCons icon
Cons
  • Only covers cats and dogs
  • Wellness care costs extra
topThree icon
Our Top 3 Picks
Prudent Pet at a Glance
8.4Editorial Score
Fee Structure Variety
9.0
Multiple deductible options, various reimbursement levels, offers many premium plans with limited customization
Payout Speed
7.0
Provides payouts within 10-14 days
Integration Capabilities
9.0
Integrates with several veterinary systems, mobile app for policy management, claim submission, and tracking
Security measures
9.0
Strong security protocols, encryption and multi-factor authentication, provides guidelines for users to protect their accounts
Customer support
8.0
Phone and email support, hours are unclear, live chat available
Most Commonly Asked Questions About Pet Insurance Plans
Before getting started with a pet insurance plan make sure to familiarize yourself with how pet insurance works and what plan is best for your furry friend. To help you get started, we've compiled a list of some of the most commonly asked questions about pet insurance to help make sure your dog or cat is fully covered and protected.
What is Pet Insurance?
Whether you have a cat or a dog, your pet will more than likely need to see a vet at some point. Seeing a vet is not cheap, and vet bills can add up, sometimes costing you thousands of dollars a year. Rather than paying for medical expenses out of pocket, signing up for a pet insurance plan will help cover the costs of future routine and emergency veterinary bills.
How Does Pet Insurance Work?
Pet insurance works a lot like human health insurance in that plans include payment features like deductibles, co-pays, maximum coverage, premiums, waiting periods, and no coverage for pre-existing conditions.

Deductible: Customers pay a small amount before the insurance company covers the remaining costs of the vet bills. Per-incident deductibles incur for each new expense. An annual deductible refers to money the customer must pay each year.

Co-pay: Co-pay is the percentage customers pay after the deductible. Then the insurer will pay the remaining amount. For example, if your co-pay is 10%, the insurer will cover 90% of the bill.

Maximum coverage: Insurers will limit the amount covered. After that, the pet owner will need to pay the rest. Some insurers have the option of unlimited coverage.

Premium: The amount of money the customer pays monthly for pet insurance. Waiting period: The amount of time before your coverage starts. Sometimes pet insurance providers will not cover an illness or injury if it occurs during the waiting period.

Pre-existing conditions: Pet insurance providers do not cover pre-existing. This refers to a health condition that exists prior to the insurance coverage.
What does Pet Insurance Cover?
Each pet insurance provider has its own customized insurance policies. The extent of the coverage will depend on the provider and plan that you choose.

When choosing a plan, consider whether you want the following types of coverage depending on the needs of your pet:
  • Preventative/wellness care
    • Hereditary conditions
      • Dental care
        • Unexpected illness and injuries
          • Diagnostic tests
            • Surgeries Hospitalizations
              • Medication Supplements or prescription food

                If your pet is at greater risk for certain medical treatments due to its breed or age, you might want to consider choosing a provider and plan that covers breed-specific and genetic conditions. However, it is important to note that most providers do not provide coverage for pre-existing conditions.
Can Pet Insurance Save You Money?
Medical bills, even for pets, can end up costing a lot of money. Paying out of pocket could cost you thousands of dollars and lead to debt. If you own a pet, paying a little now can save you a lot later on.

With our list of the top pet insurance companies, you can shop around for the best option for your pet to ensure you get a good deal for quality coverage.
Back To Top